Why Did I Serve 16 Years for Murder When I Didn't Kill Anyone? | NYT Opinion

Share
HTML-code
  • Published: 22 July 2019
  • In 2003, Adnan Khan committed a robbery in which one of his accomplices unexpectedly killed their victim. The prosecutors, judge and jury all agreed Khan did not plan or commit the murder. Yet he was still sentenced as if he had — and given a life sentence.
    The reason is the felony murder rule, an arcane piece of legal doctrine that allows all accomplices to be held equally responsible for deaths that happen in the committing of a felony.
    Researchers estimate as many as one in five people serving long life sentences did not actually kill anyone.
    In this video Op-Ed, Khan argues that it is time for the felony murder rule to be changed in every state, as it was in California last year. One of the basic principles of a fair justice system is that you are punished for the crimes you commit, not those committed by other people.

    Subscribe: bit.ly/U8Ys7n
    More from The New York Times Video: nytimes.com/video
    ----------
    Whether it's reporting on conflicts abroad and political divisions at home, or covering the latest style trends and scientific developments, New York Times video journalists provide a revealing and unforgettable view of the world. It's all the news that's fit to watch.

Comments • 2 520

  • [RS] Hori
    [RS] Hori  14 hours back

    Dura lex sed lex

    • Jape H
      Jape H  5 days back

      Stopped at 3:22 .....Dude, by your argument shop keeps and homeowners should just lay down for criminals much like yourself and not defend their lives and property. If you're stupid enough to go with a buddy into a dangerous situation and someone dies including your buddy, you're right the killer should be held responsible. How by your logic would this happen? The cops are not responsible for your stupidity, neither is your victim. Ultimately your buddy is responsible for his death, but the next best thing is his partner in crime. Also if your buddy kills the person you're robbing of course you should be held responsible for that, it's a foreseeable outcome of your activities.

      The felony murder rule is great, sorry you went to prison, but you pretty much got what you deserved. At least you didn't end up like your victim...

      Also ignorance of the law is never an excuse. Know the laws of your land bud.

      • Aeriozz
        Aeriozz  3 weeks back

        bruh

        • lupe avalos
          lupe avalos  3 weeks back

          I will protest

          • Dominike Dominike
            Dominike Dominike  3 weeks back

            He looks good for 34 being in prison and all

            • Tasnim Jawhar
              Tasnim Jawhar  3 weeks back

              WHAT??!! This is what you call a law??!! I thank God that I am a Muslim and my religion is the most just in the entire world.

              • John Galactus
                John Galactus  3 weeks back

                Another Murica only thing that makes no sense whatsoever. Unbelievable.

                • Austin Brister
                  Austin Brister  3 weeks back

                  As a new father, with two twin babies at home, I think I'll probably just suggest that my son and daughter just refrain from conspiring with accomplices to commit robbery or other felonies.

                  • Memegon
                    Memegon  4 weeks back

                    so that means, there are 36,000 people who are people who commited small crimes and fellonys?

                    • strawberry roses
                      strawberry roses  4 weeks back

                      oof

                      • joshua willix
                        joshua willix  4 weeks back

                        hes right though he shouldnt be serving prison time for a crime he didnt commit the laws these days are stupid no wonder why its broken lots of times

                        • Atley Robison
                          Atley Robison  4 weeks back

                          Based on that law, should gun shops be charged for shootings?

                          • paul johnson
                            paul johnson  3 weeks back

                            Only if the gun shop owner knows the buyer is going to use the gun to commit a felony, and stupid enough to admit to cops that he knew.

                        • Amz Hansen
                          Amz Hansen  4 weeks back

                          And Americans still thinks they´re so smart and perfect. 😂

                          • Awais Hussain
                            Awais Hussain  4 weeks back

                            Land of the free, home of the brave 😂😂😂😂😂

                            • Hammad
                              Hammad  4 weeks back

                              how does a dude named adnan khan get a latino accent

                              • TiaSelections
                                TiaSelections  4 weeks back

                                If you participate in serious crime leading to death... this sounds fair.

                                • malon
                                  malon  3 weeks back

                                  TiaSelections no it does not. Why should you be put in jail if someone else did the crime. If you have no intent to commit a murder why should you be in prison for someone else’s mistake. “Sounds fair” even the people who enforce the law agree is stupid, so i dont know if you’re trying to be different or whatever but i would like to see you in his place even for a year i know you would change your mind real fast so dont be coming with that bs.

                              • G H
                                G H  4 weeks back

                                nice watch bruh!

                                • Muffin Monster
                                  Muffin Monster  4 weeks back

                                  that's awful, 16 years gone to waste

                                  • AdameCZek
                                    AdameCZek  4 weeks back

                                    This is bruh moment right here

                                    • Zzzonko Ard
                                      Zzzonko Ard  4 weeks back

                                      Free my Boy Adnan khan

                                      • urmominabox87
                                        urmominabox87  4 weeks back

                                        Well you made the decision to engage in an activity where someone's death is a very real and foreseeable possible outcome, basically if you sow it you reap its benefits

                                        • YoYo
                                          YoYo  4 weeks back

                                          USA is trash, thank god im from EU.

                                          • Katherine L
                                            Katherine L  4 weeks back

                                            yeah that's why my parents would always tell me to never stick with the bad crowd

                                            • a l
                                              a l  4 weeks back

                                              Stupid world

                                              • a l
                                                a l  4 weeks back

                                                !!!

                                              • a l
                                                a l  4 weeks back

                                                ....I'm fed up...

                                              • a l
                                                a l  4 weeks back

                                                Just wanna die?

                                            • mmatucha1984
                                              mmatucha1984  4 weeks back

                                              this is a great rule

                                              • Cheyenne Jefferson
                                                Cheyenne Jefferson  4 weeks back

                                                I don’t think the law is wrong, just don’t commit felonies😐... tbh it’s crazy that this guy is defending committing felonies and it’s even crazier that people are agreeing with him like how would you feel if your child was killed while someone was committing a felony? If that person hadn’t committed that felony your son or daughter would still be alive so them getting charged with murder is them getting what’s coming to them..🤷‍♀️

                                                • James
                                                  James  4 weeks back

                                                  Because the court system is broken

                                                  • Im Dronn
                                                    Im Dronn  4 weeks back

                                                    What if youre robbing a place and someone there just kills them selves. Would you still go to jail for murder?

                                                    • TheCrazyCupcakeKid
                                                      TheCrazyCupcakeKid  4 weeks back

                                                      This is so messed up

                                                      • Jade Sharpe
                                                        Jade Sharpe  4 weeks back

                                                        god bless this man and so many other people that have been convicted for crimes that they didn't commit. 16 years is more than enough time to learn a lesson about not committing a robbery. The US justice system is so corrupt and focused on profit rather than actual justice.

                                                        • normal2
                                                          normal2  4 weeks back

                                                          This is how they done Tay-k smh

                                                          • REACTORVISUAL
                                                            REACTORVISUAL  4 weeks back

                                                            i Know is though, but if this rule would be masively known by population, at least 5% les crimes would be committed, specially weapons involved wich would translate in a greater percentage of deaths. if rule gets changes accomplices should still be punished if someone gets killed, maybe not for murder, but getting 15 to 30 for "murder accomplice" instead of "Murder"should be fair, at least if the victim is the one who dies, I don't agree if the partner in crime is the one who dies, but again all this would make felons think twice if they know and start looking for a job like decent people do.

                                                            • BOSJESMANN
                                                              BOSJESMANN  4 weeks back

                                                              A system in america that doesnt work very well? shocker xD

                                                              • Gamerzfolife
                                                                Gamerzfolife  4 weeks back

                                                                Adnan Khan is an Indian television actor known for his portrayal of Mawlawi Kabeer Ahmad in Zee TV's daily soap, Ishq Subhan Allah. Wikipedia
                                                                Born: December 24, 1988 (age 30 years), Dubai, United Arab Emirates
                                                                Parent(s): Ehtesham Ali Khan (father); Rukhsana Khan (mother)
                                                                Education: Manipal Academy of Higher Education - Dubai Campus (2009), GEMS Our Own English High School
                                                                its fake...

                                                            • Little Pankek
                                                              Little Pankek  4 weeks back

                                                              See, here's where I disagree. If you're both partners in crime at the start, even if you "failed" to see any possible way of accidentally murdering someone, you are still both held responsible. Now, if it was nobody you knew, and you were alone at a liquor store minding your own business when someone got murdered, sure, I'd agree with you. Do you get my point? You're pussying out when it's convenient for you and pretending like it's only your partner's fault despite agreeing to be partners in crime and commit a literal crime TOGETHER.

                                                              • Jesus Christ
                                                                Jesus Christ  4 weeks back

                                                                Crimes that are non-violent should be met with fines, crimes that are violent should be met with jail time, any crime a person does only applies to affiliates that expected the crime be done; for example people can expect to rob a place, but not expect someone to commit murder. That’s my theory on what the basis of all laws regarding crimes should be.

                                                                • sKeiT
                                                                  sKeiT  4 weeks back

                                                                  NA LULW

                                                                  • dfgdfg dsads
                                                                    dfgdfg dsads  4 weeks back

                                                                    mashallalh alhumidllah inshallah better

                                                                    • Eigil Holm Haxø
                                                                      Eigil Holm Haxø  4 weeks back

                                                                      free Tay-K

                                                                      • Blake Lawson
                                                                        Blake Lawson  4 weeks back

                                                                        Maybe it shouldn't be life in prison, but i think it's totally fair to blame a death on them when it was their actions that led to their death. They knew what they were doing when they committed the felony, and they should take responsibility what their actions caused.

                                                                        • General Hi Ping
                                                                          General Hi Ping  4 weeks back

                                                                          “Land of the free” they say

                                                                          • Zeime
                                                                            Zeime  4 weeks back

                                                                            You feel so inspired and look up to him but then you realize that he was a thief.

                                                                            • Muba Cali
                                                                              Muba Cali  4 weeks back

                                                                              Sharia law would never

                                                                              • Петър Василев

                                                                                The UK actually has something that’s similar but in a lighter form. Its called Unlawful Act Manslaughter.

                                                                                • Dustey
                                                                                  Dustey  4 weeks back

                                                                                  maybe dont commit a felony faceass

                                                                                  • Raven359
                                                                                    Raven359  4 weeks back

                                                                                    this is stupid

                                                                                    • Ganesh Menon
                                                                                      Ganesh Menon  4 weeks back

                                                                                      So there are still geniuses like him still in Prison.

                                                                                      • Boss Boys
                                                                                        Boss Boys  4 weeks back

                                                                                        I’m in mass so Yeet America loooooooooooool

                                                                                        • xx muerto
                                                                                          xx muerto  4 weeks back

                                                                                          #freetayk