Joe Judge was a far more surprising hire than Matt Rhule — Shannon Sharpe | NFL | UNDISPUTED


Comments • 510

  • Skip and Shannon: UNDISPUTED

    Were you surprised by any of the recent NFL coaching hires?

    • Greywolfwarrior
      Greywolfwarrior  2 weeks back

      My new snow storm ride

    • TheSlasher 466
      TheSlasher 466  2 weeks back

      Oh yea we had Gene Smith start so your wrong

    • TheSlasher 466
      TheSlasher 466  2 weeks back

      Master dude what does that matter at all this doesn’t even tie into the subject

    • TheSlasher 466
      TheSlasher 466  2 weeks back

      Nephew Hill yea but special teams has done rlly well for The Patriots

    • El Dizzy
      El Dizzy  2 weeks back

      I'm not surprised by anything that happens in corporate America. I've seen some mind boggling decisions.

  • spartanclams
    spartanclams  16 hours back

    no one knows just like the draft eh. he must get a good staff and system to succeed

    • fuckinmetal1982
      fuckinmetal1982  5 days back

      life-long giants fan. i didnt really understand the firing of pat shurmur as it was his first season with a rookie qb and didn't really understand what Mara was expecting from him. regardless, this is a good hire. We won't know until we know, but i like judge as head coach of the giants.

      • Vbat 421
        Vbat 421  1 weeks back

        All the coaches hiring were so strange this year. What is up with all the rookie coaches? The NFL wants new blood but the Giants, Panthers and Browns? Eh

        • Just Another Brother
          Just Another Brother  1 weeks back

          Stop the faking. Just shred the Rooney Rule. It obviously has no impact...It is what it is.

          • Yannick Madou
            Yannick Madou  1 weeks back

            Jim zorn for the redskins was pretty shocking 😂

            • William Ross
              William Ross  1 weeks back

              No Skip....just like Cowherd....THEY DID NOT PANIC. They didnt want to match the 70 million dollar 7 year contract plus the 60 million dollar buyout. That's legitimately the only reason Rhule is in Carolina. Period. And who cares. Giants just got Saban and Belichicks protege

              • jason jones
                jason jones  1 weeks back

                They connect because of race

                • SASUKE UCHIHA
                  SASUKE UCHIHA  2 weeks back

                  i am the law i am judge jury and executioner.

                  • Jordan Laurenzo
                    Jordan Laurenzo  2 weeks back

                    Judge is goin be a suprise gem , Shannon sorry bruh but I disagree wit ya 🤷🏼‍♂️

                    • Eric Toomer
                      Eric Toomer  2 weeks back

                      So let me get this straight, Matt Rhule gets a freaking 7-Year Deal worth $60 Million and up to $70 with incentives being reached with the Carolina Panthers after 1 good year with Baylor and finishing up the season getting their butts whooped by Georgia. Also, he barely has a winning record and doesn’t without last year’s season 🤨❗️And then you got Joe Judge, Yes I didn’t know who the heck he was either getting the New York Giants Job off coaching New England Special Teams And Wide Receivers who were EASILY THE WORST in the league (cue Jhene Aiko “The Worst” Song)! All this Bullcorn happening while Jim Caldwell, a proven and very good coach gets ZERO OFFERS and a guy like Eric Bieniemy gets interviewed by multiple squads AGAIN, but is unlikely to get a job including Cleveland after he and Andy Reid has THE MOST EXPLOSIVE Offense in the NFL Bar None❗️There are others, but what I say is not only is this aforementioned BS, but if this doesn’t get most of those weak a** Black NFL Players to rise up and be STRONG BLACK MEN for their Black/African Brethren in Coaching and they do that BS like they did with Kap, Double 🖕🏾🖕🏾 to those 🙀 #No Balls #CBA in 2021 #Those Negros about to get WORKED like government mules #No Leadership #No Visionaries 🙄🙄🙄

                      • Eric Toomer
                        Eric Toomer  1 weeks back

                        @FlameWingMan He led them to a Super Bowl Win in his 2nd Year against my then favorite squad the Arizona Cardinals, but see if I'm not mistaken, they were at least an average team before he took over and he took them to new heights moving forward, but that wasn't a horrid situation.

                      • FlameWingMan
                        FlameWingMan  1 weeks back

                        Eric Toomer I wouldn’t say it’s unrealistic but it’s possible...look at the Steelers for example when coach Coward retired from coaching after winning the SB and they Steelers brought in Tomlin didn’t he win it his 1st/2nd year??

                      • Eric Toomer
                        Eric Toomer  2 weeks back

                        @FlameWingMan And that is so unrealistic because you hire a coach usually because your team isn't good and to expect a turnaround that quickly is pretty close to delusional. They went 10-6 that year, but remember, Fitzpatrick threw 3 picks in the 4th against Buffalo to throw away that game and miss the playoffs(no pun intended).

                      • FlameWingMan
                        FlameWingMan  2 weeks back

                        @Eric Toomer here's the thing these GMs and Owners expect you to be winning and in the playoffs by year 2. Now Bowles got another year because he took the Jets to the playoffs his 1st year

                      • Eric Toomer
                        Eric Toomer  2 weeks back

                        @FlameWingMan Okay... just like Doug Pederson and Matt Nagy and they got jobs out of nowhere and Eric is a known hot candidate as opposed to those two.
                        Brian Flores- Exceeded Expectations for a sorry team

                        Mike Tomlin- 8-8 with that squad... ENOUGH SAID
                        Ron Rivera- Deserving
                        Anthony Lynn- Very Good Coach and one bad season shouldn't change that
                        Hue Jackson- Deserved to be canned
                        Vance Joseph- 7-9 for a well-below average Broncos team; shouldn't have been fired
                        Todd Bowles- Deserved another year with Darnold and Company e.g. Better QB Play
                        Steve Wilks- ONE FREAKING YEAR for the worst team in the NFL... Messed Up

                        Only Hue deserved to be fired in my humble opinion, the ones that got fired were unfairly fired.

                    • Taipan 1 2 3
                      Taipan 1 2 3  2 weeks back

                      It pays to be white, White Privilege, the biggest affirmative action system in the world, 400 years and counting...

                      • Vintage Vitamin J
                        Vintage Vitamin J  2 weeks back

                        We need more Brady and Cowboys stories.

                        • AquamenHD R
                          AquamenHD R  2 weeks back

                          As a giants fan, they will be last on the division next year!!! I guarantee it!! Lol

                          • CHINO LOPEZ
                            CHINO LOPEZ  2 weeks back

                            Josh McDaniels ...
                            Eric Bieniemy...
                            Kris Richard...
                            Urban Meyer...
                            Were the only real choices for the Giants to choose from. They would’ve all been unproven choices. We could’ve all made an argument as to how they could fail as a head coach. Matt Rhule is not proven anything yet. Most of these college coaches that don’t have NFL experience fail. The choice to get Judge feels like the Daniel Jones pick. We will have to wait and see how these next two seasons go. I’m a GIANTS fan and I’m hoping for the best. 🤞🏽

                            • R JiZzLe
                              R JiZzLe  2 weeks back

                              Another no name White man

                              • Tommy Ribs
                                Tommy Ribs  2 weeks back

                                Rhule is a good hire. I hope Judge is. Time will tell with both of these.

                                • John Black
                                  John Black  2 weeks back

                                  White bias in hiring people they are comfortable with who reflect their image back to them. This is bias in hiring and elements people of difference who may be more qualified. When is systemic it is racism. The NFL has to be called on its racism. Look at character (MLK), the heart (Jesus) and success, experience and other attributes, not just seeing someone who looks like themselves.

                                  • Rogue Shaddo
                                    Rogue Shaddo  2 weeks back

                                    "The NFL is a totally different ball game."

                                    Well, technically...

                                    • YngGodDre
                                      YngGodDre  2 weeks back

                                      Jenny talking spicy today alright!! Lol

                                      • Thunder Nation
                                        Thunder Nation  2 weeks back

                                        They really running out of content

                                        • Thunder Nation
                                          Thunder Nation  5 days back

                                          Slab Szn pretty low compared to the rest of their segments like this. Additionally, just because it gets views doesn’t mean they haven’t had these same takes in previous videos. Recycled content m8.

                                        • Slab Szn
                                          Slab Szn  5 days back

                                          Thunder Nation 250k views tho? 🧐

                                      • robert colaluca
                                        robert colaluca  2 weeks back

                                        just curious how belichick feels about one of his assistants coaching his beloved giants

                                        • Tim Snortin'
                                          Tim Snortin'  2 weeks back

                                          Shannon with the Sunk Cost Fallacy, the 6 mil was gone already

                                          • Blessed Disciple
                                            Blessed Disciple  2 weeks back

                                            Let this be another example of sports teams not caring for their fans ( who pay the salaries of the franchise ). Stop wasting time emotionally & financially investing in them. "Your team" doesn't love you and never will. They hire wack coaches, wack players, and have no problem losing...but charging you $150 to sit in an okay seat at the game. It's entertainment, there's no loyalty in it for you.

                                            • Virgil R
                                              Virgil R  2 weeks back

                                              #Stop it Skip?
                                              Aaron #Judge!

                                              • Josh W
                                                Josh W  2 weeks back

                                                Same retread argument people were saying for John Harbaugh and Mike Tomlin who were either ST coordinator or DB coordinator before becoming a HC. Judge will surprise a lot of people

                                                • Sassonic
                                                  Sassonic  2 weeks back

                                                  Can anyone explain why Shannon calls Caron Wentz "Walk in to 'em." I don't get the nickname.

                                                  • Sean Berberich
                                                    Sean Berberich  2 weeks back

                                                    NFC East rivals like Dallas want the Giants to lose...even they are like..huh? We wanna win 24-21 not is goin on

                                                    • Pac West
                                                      Pac West  2 weeks back

                                                      Should have went after Urban or Bill Cowher, this will be the third strike in 5 years for the GIants.

                                                      • MrRufusRToyota
                                                        MrRufusRToyota  2 weeks back

                                                        Stupid contract, but it got started by the Raiders. Agents are negotiating based on Gruden’s 10-year, $10M/year contract, and now college coaches are getting 7-year, $9M/year contracts. The last time coaching salaries jumped in the NFL was when the Redskins gave Spurrier a stupid contract to come out of college. Didn’t go well, but everybody’s salaries took a permanent jump.

                                                        • KJEdward CookeIII
                                                          KJEdward CookeIII  2 weeks back

                                                          There's only ONE JUDGE! in NYC/Jersey.. and he's named Aaron..

                                                          • taco meat
                                                            taco meat  2 weeks back

                                                            Go ahead judge Judge if you will, but the Rhule is to wait until they fail.

                                                            • Breeze Brown
                                                              Breeze Brown  2 weeks back

                                                              To bad it didn’t happen like this lol 🤦🏽‍♂️

                                                              • Antonyo Sprow
                                                                Antonyo Sprow  2 weeks back

                                                                Judge 👨‍⚖️ 🤣 0:02

                                                                • CHEF DISASTER
                                                                  CHEF DISASTER  2 weeks back

                                                                  They don't want to hire black coaches

                                                                  • ramsfire
                                                                    ramsfire  2 weeks back

                                                                    Pretty obvious they went for Youth instead of experience. How do you let Mike McCarthy go to a Division Rival?

                                                                    • Marcelo Soprano
                                                                      Marcelo Soprano  2 weeks back

                                                                      Should have been Jim Harbaugh or Urban Meyer. The Mara’s and Tishes are turning into the Jets owner...they ruined everything when they fired Coughlin..

                                                                      • Abdulla Abu-Zayed
                                                                        Abdulla Abu-Zayed  2 weeks back

                                                                        I like Shannon and all but him bitching about unfairness is kinda silly. These owners can hire whomever they want.

                                                                        • ZhangtheGreat
                                                                          ZhangtheGreat  2 weeks back

                                                                          Last I checked, coaches that came from the Bill Belichick tree haven't been decent. Mangini? Crennell? McDaniels? Heck, even Charlie Weis at Notre Dame? The only Belichick guy who has had somewhat decent success so far has been Bill O'Brien. Both Mike Vrabel and Brian Flores are on "wait and see" status right now. Matt Patricia might be axed next year if he can't get it together and start winning more. I'm not sure what the Giants see in Joe Judge...

                                                                          If you want a better chance, hire a guy from the Andy Reid coaching tree. John Harbaugh and Doug Pederson are Super Bowl champions. Ron Rivera has gotten to a Super Bowl. Sean McDermott has the Bills playing the best football in nearly two decades. Even Brad Childress got to an NFC Championship. Yes, there have been some clunkers (Steve Spagnuolo, Todd Bowles) and one "wait and see" (Matt Nagy), but Reid's tree has been far more impressive than Belichick's.

                                                                          • Quercus 53
                                                                            Quercus 53  2 weeks back

                                                                            Here comes the Judge.............he rules in The land of the Giants!

                                                                            • shane peterman
                                                                              shane peterman  2 weeks back

                                                                              McCarthy is gonna own this division, it’s gonna be Dallas vs Philly for the division for about 5 years atleast lol

                                                                              • Darnell Stokes
                                                                                Darnell Stokes  2 weeks back

                                                                                The Giants owners need to sell the team because apparently winning is not the first thing on their mind. There were to many qualified coaches available for them to go this route. The GM needs to be fired, and they talking about Jason as the OC.

                                                                                • Justin Marion
                                                                                  Justin Marion  2 weeks back

                                                                                  The new owner, firing our coach and hiring Matt makes me very nervous as a Panthers fan

                                                                                  • Quincee 33
                                                                                    Quincee 33  2 weeks back

                                                                                    Mike Judge > Joe Judge .

                                                                                    • Tez Jackson
                                                                                      Tez Jackson  2 weeks back

                                                                                      U can’t bridge Jason to the Giants really and You telling me this not for pay back against the Cowboys

                                                                                      • Tez Jackson
                                                                                        Tez Jackson  2 weeks back

                                                                                        I think this Judge Hire is really saying Jason is the Head Coach and Judge is just there to take the blame for the loses then Jason gone take over after Judge is booed out of New York

                                                                                        • Tez Jackson
                                                                                          Tez Jackson  2 weeks back

                                                                                          I am not trynna knock anybody down but this is the nfl and Brother you can’t be going 2-14 then 6-10 then 8-8 because there looking to win now and You want the fans to know hey we made the right pick

                                                                                          • Tez Jackson
                                                                                            Tez Jackson  2 weeks back

                                                                                            They must think these Coach’s are Jimmy Johnson or Something